Overview
The first four books in the New Testament are called ‘the Gospels’ and they are Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John. Among them, the very first three, that is, the gospel according to Matthew, Mark, and Luke, are grouped together and called as Synoptic Gospels1; and the fourth gospel, the gospel according to John, is referred to as Johannine gospel. The first three gospels are called Synoptic Gospels because each writer includes the narrative of Jesus’ life and ministry. This narrative includes miracles, signs, wonders that Jesus performed, Jesus’ death, resurrection, and ascension, and other teachings that are very similar in their content, expression of thought, and order. Most of what is read in the Synoptic Gospels are not recorded in the Johannine gospel. John focuses more on Jesus’ ministry rather than His life-history. Much of Jesus’ teachings that are recorded in the synoptic Gospels are not repeated in John’s gospel, and this gives the book of John a unique place among the gospels.
The English word synoptic is derived from the Greek word συνοπτικός (synoptikós), which has its origin from two Greek words συν (syn) meaning ‘together’ and οπτικ (optic), meaning ‘seen or seeing.’ Thus, the term συνοπτικός (synoptikós), means ‘seen together’ or ‘seeing similar.’ This ‘seeing together’ principle allows the reader to identify that each gospel has, on one hand, so much in common with the other two gospels and much similarity in their contents and writing sequence; on the other hand, as one studies each of the gospels carefully, they can understand that there are also some dissimilarities in their appearance, contexts, and writing sequences. Such a literary relationship and interdependence of these three gospels (Matthew, Mark, and Luke) leads to a problem, which is generally known as the synoptic problem. The questions raised here are that, ‘If there are similarities in its contents, structure, context, and so on, what is the need of having three different gospels?’ and ‘If they are three different gospels, why are there so much of similarities between the gospels?’
Similarities Among the Synoptic Gospels
The gospels according to Matthew, Mark, and Luke were written by either an eye-witness or the close-companions of the eyewitnesses of Jesus’ life and ministry. For instance, the gospel according to Matthew is written by Matthew, one among ‘The Twelve,’ and an eyewitness of Jesus’ life and ministry; and Mark, was one of the ministry companions of Apostle Peter who was one among the Twelve and an eye witness of Jesus life and ministry; and Luke, a physician, was one of the ministry associates of Apostle Paul, who had a personal encounter with the glorified Christ near the city gate at Damascus (Acts 9:1-31), and later received the revelation and message of Jesus directly from the glorified Christ (Galatians 1:11-12). So, one can observe the visible similarities in all three gospels. They all noted down the teachings of Jesus and the events that took place in His ministry.
Differences Among the Synoptic Gospels
All the authors of the gospels, in this case the synoptic gospel writers, recorded the life, teachings and ministry of Jesus as the Holy Spirit revealed to them. However, they used their own personal skills, methods, styles, purposes, and sources to write it down. This makes each of the gospels unique in their appearance and presentation.
There has much research and discussions done on the Synoptic problem, but no one has been able to find any solution. Although this study will not delve too deeply into the discussion of the Synoptic Problem, below are a few potential solutions which were proposed by scholars to understand how each author used their resources to write their respective gospel:
- All three writers, that is, Matthew, Mark, and Luke, referred to some common source, perhaps ‘Q Source’,2 for their writings
- Mark wrote his gospel first and later Matthew and Luke referred to Mark’s gospel and wrote theirs
- Matthew and Luke primarily used their own available sources and referred to Mark’s gospel and ‘Q Source’ for their writings
- Mark wrote his gospel on his own but Matthew and Luke used a common source as their reference [perhaps ‘Q Source’]
- Matthew wrote his gospel first, then Luke used Matthew’s gospel as reference for his writings, and later Mark used Matthew and Luke for his references
- Luke used his own available sources and referred to Matthew, Mark and ‘Q Source’ to write the gospel according to Luke
The Proportions
Similarity Proportions:
- 45-47% of Matthew’s writings are found both in the gospels of Mark and Luke
- 70-72% of Mark’s writings are found both in the gospels of Matthew and Luke
- 40-42% of Luke’s writings are found both in the gospels of Matthew and Mark
Dissimilarity Proportions:
- 20% of Matthew’s writing is not found in any other gospels
- 3% of Mark’s writing is not found in any other gospels
- 35% of Luke’s writing is not found in any other gospels.
It is widely accepted among the Bible historians that each of the Synoptic Gospels is originally written to the recipients who’s identity and context were different from one another. For instance, the gospel according to Matthew (written to Jewish Christians) and Mark (written to Roman Christians), were written to a wider community while the gospel according Luke is addressed to Theophilus who is either an individual or anyone who loves God – representing the wider community of Gentile Christians. Despite all the obvious similarities and dissimilarities between these gospels, none of these authors disagree or contradict with one another in presenting Jesus, his teachings, and his ministry. Rather, each of these gospels upheld the divine and eternal purpose of Christ’s coming to Earth. Therefore, each of these gospels should be studied together and side-by-side for the benefit of the reader as well as the Church community.
The Gospel according to Matthew3
Matthew was placed right at the beginning of NT in order to emphasis its relationship to the Old Testament. Matthew draws many references from the Old Testament regarding Jesus’ life, ministry and the prophetic fulfillment.
- Authorship: It is accepted that Matthew, one of the Twelve Disciples, wrote the Gospel of Matthew
- Date of Writing: It is written sometime between 60 and 65 AD.
- Recipients: Matthew mainly wrote to the Greek-speaking Jewish Christians in Palestine. So, he
- Quoted frequently from the Old Testament Scripture in order to highlight that several of the Old Testament prophets prophesied about the coming of the Messiah (for instance: Genesis 3:15; Psalms 22:1-22; Isaiah 7:13-14; 49:6; 53:1-12; Daniel 7:13-14; Micah 5:2-4)
- Presented Jesus Christ as the long-awaited Messiah of the Old Testament, the promised King of Israel in the line of king David (Matthew 1:1; 9:27; 12:23; 15:22; 20:30-31; 21:9,15; 22:41-45), who came to save the Jews as well as the Gentiles (Matthew 2:1-12; 8:11-12; 13:38; 21:43; 28:18-20).
- Uses the phrase ‘The Kingdom of Heaven’ rather than ‘the Kingdom of God’ as in the gospels of Mark and Luke
Matthew’s four key focus on Jesus’ teachings:
- The Beatitudes (Matthew 5:3-12)
- The Lord’s prayer (Matthew 6:9-13)
- The Golden Rule (Matthew 7:12) [the royal law, James 2:8; the golden standard, 1 Timothy 3:1-7]
- The Great Commission (Matthew 28:18-20)
Five discourses of Jesus found in Matthew
How do we know which parts of the Gospel are the teachings of the Lord? Each instance where Jesus concluded His teachings, it is written ‘when Jesus had finished these sayings.’ This phrase repeats five times through out the gospel (Matthew 7:28; 11:1; 13:53; 19:1; and 26:1):
- The Sermon on the Mount (Matthew 5-7): These are the moral teachings of Jesus
- The Commissioning of the Twelve (Matthew 10),
- The Parables of the Kingdom (Matthew 13):
- Parable of the Sower (Matthew 13:1-23)
- Parable of Weeds (Matthew 13:24-30; 36-43)
- Parable of Mustard Seed (Matthew 13:31-32)
- Parables of Leaven (Matthew 13:33)
- Parable of Hidden Treasure (Matthew 13:44)
- Parable of Pearl (Matthew 13:45-46)
- Parable of Net (Matthew 13:47-50)
- Parable of Householder (Matthew 13:51-53)
- The Discourse on the Church (Matthew 18)
- The Olivet Discourse (Matthew 23-25)
Matthew’s use of Numbers
The favorite number of Matthew was 3 [However, numbers like 5 and 7 are also used in several occasions]. Examples of the use of the number three are below:
- the threefold division of the genealogy of Jesus Christ (Matthew 1:17):
- from Abraham to David,
- fourteen from David to the exile to Babylon
- fourteen from the exile to the Messiah
- the three temptations (Matthew 4:1-11):
- Related to hunger
- Related to love and care
- Related to worship
- the three illustrations of righteousness (Matthew 6:1-18):
- Giving
- Praying
- Fasting
- the three types of miracles (Matthew 8:1 – 9:34):
- Healings
- Power/Authority
- Restoration
Only in Matthew
- The Annunciation of Jesus’ birth to Joseph (Matthew 1:18-25)
- The visit of the wise men [the Magi] (Matthew 2:1-12)
- Escape of Joseph and Mary with infant Jesus to Egypt (Matthew 2:13-15)
- Slaughter of infants in Nazareth (Matthew 2:16-18)
- Jesus finds new home in Capernaum (Matthew 4:13-16)
- Healing of two blind men (Matthew 9:27-31)
- Pharisee’s blasphemous accusation (Matthew 9:32-34)
- Jesus and God the father (Matthew 11:25-30)
- Jesus’ refusal to give a sign to the Pharisees and Scribes (Matthew 12:38-45)
- Parable of weeds (Matthew 13:24-30, 36-43)
The Gospel according to Mark4
- Authorship: It is believed that the gospel of Mark is written by John Mark
- Date of writing: It is believed to be written between 55 and 65 AD.
- Interesting Facts:
- The gospel according to Mark is the shortest of all the gospels
- It is believed that Mark is likely to be the first written gospel
- Mark’s gospel mainly focused on the Roman Christians
- Mark presented Jesus as the [suffering] Servant of God, which shows that Jesus came to serve
- Mark’s gospel focuses equally on Jesus’ words as well as His deeds, which reveals that Jesus means what He says and He does what He says
Only in Mark
- Parable of Seed growing by itself (Mark 4:26-29)
The Gospel according to Luke5
- Authorship: Luke, also known as Levi, the tax collector. He is also mentioned in Colossians 4:14 as a physician. Luke, being a faithful friend and travel companion of Apostle Paul, gathered the resources from Jesus’ disciples and other eyewitnesses of Jesus’ life and ministry (Luke 1:1-4)
- Date of Writing: Sometime early in the decade of 60 AD.
- Recipients: It was originally written to Theophilus (meaning, the one who loves God). However, Luke, being the only Gentile New Testament writer, wrote his gospel mainly to the Gentile Christian believers, especially to those who loved God
- Luke focused on the humanity of Jesus Christ and presented Him as the Son of Man who came to seek and to save what was lost in Israel (Luke 19:10) and extend His love for everyone (John 3:16). Luke focused more on Jesus’ compassion towards the poor, the sick, the suffering, and the sinners. He showed his genuine love towards everyone who approached Him with a need.
Only in Luke:
- The source of Luke’s gospel is recorded in Luke 1:1-4
- Announcement of John’s birth to Zacharias (Luke 1:5-25)
- Annunciation of Jesus’ birth to Mary (Luke 1:26-38)
- Song of Elizabeth upon Mary’s visit (Luke 1:39-45)
- Mary’s response to Elizabeth’s greetings (Luke 1:46-56)
- Birth and early life of John the Baptist (Luke 1:57-80)
- The birth of Jesus in Bethlehem (Luke 2:1-7)
- The birth of Jesus is announced to the shepherds by the angels (Luke 2:8-20)
- The circumcision of Jesus at Bethlehem and the presentation of Jesus at the temple (Luke 2:21-38)
- Visit to Jerusalem when Jesus was the age of twelve (Luke 2:40-52)
- Jesus’ rejection at Nazareth (Luke 4:16-30)
- Widow’s son at Nain raised (Luke 7:11-17)
- Anointing of Jesus by a sinful woman in Simon the Pharisee’s house (Luke 7:36-50)
Elaboration (of the superscripts)
It is noted that the first three gospels (Matthew, Mark, and Luke) grouped together are called the Synoptic Gospels since AD 1780
The letter ‘Q’ is taken from the German word ‘Quelle, means ‘source,’ which is known as ‘Q Source.’ It is believed to be a collection of Jesus’ teachings written by one of the eye-witnesses (some believe that there were unknown written gospels, existing prior to the writings of the gospels in the New Testament, which were used by the New Testament gospel writers as source material)
Apostle Matthew, also known as Levi (a native of Capernaum), was a tax collector until Jesus called him to be His disciple. He was hated by the Jews because he was appointed by the Roman authority to collect tax from Jews. Matthew, being a tax collector, must have been a highly educated and influential person in their society. Jesus called Matthew to follow Him while he was sitting at his tax collecting station and Matthew followed Jesus at once (Matthew 9:9; 10:3; Mark 2:14; 3:18; Luke 5:27; 6:15; Acts 1:13). Matthew fully obeyed Jesus by leaving his tax collecting profession behind him when he heard the voice of Jesus calling him. He became a powerful witness of Jesus’ life and ministry on Earth. In addition to the ministry he carried out, Apostle Matthew wrote the gospel according Matthew to challenge his Hebrew readers concerning the Old Testament prophecies regarding Jesus’ birth and life. He also narrated Jesus’ life, ministry, death, burial, resurrection, and ascension to heaven in detail. The highlight of his writings include the oracles and teachings of Jesus, including the Great Commission, that is, All authority in heaven and on Earth has been given to me. Therefore go and make disciples of all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit, and teaching them to obey everything I have commanded you. And surely I am with you always, to the very end of the age”(Matthew 28:18-20). Although Apostle Matthew preached in Parthia (present day Tehran in Iran), he ultimately served as a missionary in Ethiopia. Tradition says that he was martyred in Ethiopia in AD 65 while serving his Master faithfully. It is believed that his remains are kept in Saint Matthews Cathedral in the Province of Messina in Italy.
Mark was a pious and godly person who served Jesus very faithfully. Even then, his life was filled with so many twists and turns. It is believed that he was one among Jesus’ seventy disciples (Luke 10:1), he was the man who was carrying a jar of water (Mark 14:13), he was present at the time of Jesus’ arrest (Mark 14:51-52), he organized prayer meetings at his home along with his mother Mary (Acts 12:12), he was one of the missionary team members with Paul and Barnabas (Acts 13:13), he was the cousin of Barnabas (Colossians 4:10), he was with Peter during his ministry trips (1 Peter 5:13), and, finally, he became a missionary himself to Alexandria, Egypt.
Many church scholars believe that the young man (Mark 14:51-52) who was following Jesus during His arrest was the same Mark mentioned in the book Acts (Acts 12:12) in whose house the prayer meeting was going on during the imprisonment of the Apostles James and Peter. This was the reason that Apostle Peter, after being miraculously delivered by the angel of God from prison, went to the house of John, also called Mark, whose mother’s name was Mary, where many people had gathered and were praying. Some even believe that Mark was part of the seventy (or seventy-two) Jesus sent out to preach the gospel (Luke 10:1-12). Some scholars even believe that he was the person who was carrying the water about whom Jesus mentioned to His disciples (Mark 14:13). Later, Mark became a ministry associate with Apostles Paul and Barnabas during their first missionary journey to Cypress but he deserted them and returned to Jerusalem when the missionary team halted at Perga in Pamphylia (Acts 13:13). Apostles Paul and Barnabas parted each other’s friendship and ministry partnership (Acts 15:36-41) because Mark was the cousin of Barnabas and he wanted to take him with them as they were preparing for their second missionary journey (Colossians 4:10).
Later, according to early Christian tradition, Apostle Peter took Mark along with him during his ministry trips and became a great help to Peter as they travelled together to Peter’s many ministry destinations. In fact, because of Mark’s close ministry and spiritual association with Apostle Peter, he considered Mark as his son (1 Peter 5:13), like Apostle Paul considered Timothy as his spiritual son (1 Timothy 1:2).
Early Christian tradition widely accepts that Mark went as a missionary to Egypt sometime in the middle of the first century AD. The people were receptive and he preached the gospel and planted churches there. Thus, Mark is honored as the first carrier of the Gospel to Africa, particularly to Egypt. After a few centuries, the Egyptian Christians came to be known as the Copts. The title “Copts” for Christians came to exist because the early Egyptian Christians developed a language known as Coptic language using Greek alphabets and other familiar signs from their ancient Egyptian language and created a liturgy in the Coptic language. It was the common understanding that the Christians in Egypt developed Coptic language in order to make the path of gospel preaching easier and more specific.
Christian tradition also says that while Mark was serving as the first bishop in Alexandria, he authored the Gospel according to Mark based on his first-hand experience with Jesus, being one of His seventy disciples, and Peter’s preachings. This gospel primarily focused on the later part of Jesus’ life in connection with His ministry rather than Jesus’ genealogy or His early life. His purpose was to reveal and establish the identity of Jesus to his readers. Emphasizing that Jesus is the Son of God as well as the anticipated Messiah of the Hebrew Scriptures (Mark 1:1-3).
Mark served his Master very faithfully until the end of his age and served the people whom he loved. However, he became a martyr for His Lord by the hands of the idol worshippers in Alexandria. The St. Mark Coptic Orthodox Cathedral in Alexandria was built in honor him. Later, his relics were taken to Venice.
Unlike several other early Christian leaders, the life and ministry of Luke is not mentioned much in the Scripture. Apostle Paul, in the epistle to the Colossians, briefly mentioned Luke as a physician, who was known as ‘the beloved physician’ (Colossians 4:14). It is understood from the early Christian tradition that Luke was devoted to God prior to embracing the Christian faith. It is possible that he embraced the Christian faith through Apostle Paul’s ministry. Although he was considered a Gentile Christian, he followed Jesus Christ very faithfully and became a disciple and traveling companion of Apostle Paul. The detailed ministry description and the usage of ‘we’ and ‘us’ on several occasions in the book of the Acts of the Apostles, points out that Luke held an integral part in Paul’s missionary journeys and Paul’s final journey to Rome. While Apostle Paul wrote his last epistle, the epistle of Second Timothy, Paul mentioned that ‘only Luke was with him’ (2 Timothy 4:11), which shows that Luke stayed close to Apostle Paul in Roman prison up till the last minutes of Paul’s life on Earth. Perhaps, Luke witnessed the martyrdom of Apostle Paul and, possibly, was the one who buried the beheaded body of his spiritual teacher, mentor, companion in the ministry of God, fellow-ministry-traveler through the mission fields, and, above all that, his beloved friend in the Lord.
Luke might be the only Gentile writer among all New Testament writers. He wrote two books in the New Testament, the gospel according to Luke and the Acts of the Apostles. Both these books are addressed to Theophilus who is said to be an influential governor in the Roman region of Antioch. The gospel according to Luke is chiefly written for Gentiles, but also for a wider, audience. The gospel focused on the life, ministry, death, burial, resurrection and ascension of Jesus Christ and the Acts of the Apostles focused on the coming of the Holy Spirit, starting and the expansion of the New Testament Church. Luke, being himself a physician, recorded Jesus’ comments on illness and physicians more clearer than other gospel writers. For instance: “Jesus said to them, “Surely you will quote this proverb to me: ‘Physician, heal yourself!’” (Luke 4:23). On an another occasion Jesus said, “But the Pharisees and the teachers of the law who belonged to their sect complained to his disciples, “Why do you eat and drink with tax collectors and sinners?” Jesus answered them, “It is not the healthy who need a doctor, but the sick. I have not come to call the righteous, but sinners to repentance” (Luke 5:30-31). In another context, Luke highlighted the inability of his fellow physicians who had been approached by a woman for the healing of her flow of blood for twelve years. He quotes, “Now a woman, having a flow of blood for twelve years, who had spent all her livelihood on physicians and could not be healed by any” (8:43).
Early Church tradition upholds the belief that after Apostle Paul’s martyrdom, Luke became an evangelist and missionary in Thebes, specifically in the regions of Boeotia in Greece. After serving His Lord and Savior Jesus Christ for several years in Thebes, the enemies of the gospel captured him, peeled his skin while he was alive, and crucified him. Like his spiritual teacher and mentor Apostle Paul, Luke was martyred for his faith in Jesus Christ.